April 7, 2010

Dantewada: Terror and Counter-terror

This Op-ed appears in The New Indian Express on the 7th of April, 2010.

No calls for blood: A crowd gathers around a fact-finding team in the village of Vaingur, after it was raided by the Police on the 20th (?) of April, 2009. There wasn't a single call for vengeance and retribution. No anger. Just desperation. Just who are the Maoists killing for?

‘When the adivasi picks up the gun and becomes a Maoist does he really cease to be a human being? Or just as human as us?’

The killing of 73 security personnel is unprecedented in South Bastar. The previous major attack took place in Ranibodli on the 15th of March 2006 when the Maoists had attacked a police camp in the dead of night and literally butchered 55 policemen. The word ‘butchered’ would be used as there was no fair fight. The policemen were caught surprised and many of them were too inebriated to fight. By morning, the camp lay in cinders, the bodies mutilated and all the weapons had disappeared. Only three CRPF personnel had survived as they hid in the nearby tribal girl’s hostel. When Maoists inquired if anyone was there, the girls claimed there was no one with them. That was all that saved them – young tribal girls, not their guns.

Tuesday’s attack has taken place in the dead of the jungle during a combing operation at six or seven in the morning. While there have never been so many killed during encounters or ambushes in one incident, history can tell us that Maoists have consistently inflicted casualties on security forces over the last few years.

On the 19th of July 2009, 29 security personnel including the Superintendent of Police were killed in an ambush in Rajnangaon, Chhattisgarh. In Dantewada itself, 25 security personnel including SPOs were killed via the use of IEDs placed in the trees and small arms fire in Gaganpalli on the 9th of July 2007. The security personnel retreated out of the jungle and it would take them three whole days to recover the bodies of their fallen comrades.

Around a year ago, on the 10th of April 2009, 10 security personnel were killed in the forest near Chintagufa. 19 more were wounded, while only three Maoists were killed. The Maoists were soon announcing the attack as revenge for the Singaram massacre when 19 innocent tribals were allegedly killed by the security forces. But it never stops. 12 more policemen were killed in Dhamtari on the 11th of May, 2009. 12 more were killed when their truck was hit by an IED near Tongpal in Dantewada on the 20th of June, 2009. The list is almost endless.

Ambushes and IED blasts are routine affairs yet casualties can range from anywhere from 10 to none. At Koyras on the 2nd of May, 2009, an IED blast followed by gunfire left three CRPF personnel with a few scratches, while an IED blast a few days earlier near Bijapur town had killed three personnel who were traveling by an anti-landmine vehicle.

And the one thing no one (but the security personnel) want to admit, is that the Maoists are a very capable guerilla force and every time the forces enter the jungle, the PLGA or the People’s Liberation Guerilla Army have the upper-hand. Across rough hilly terrain, across thick jungle, over a hundred security personnel tend to move at a snails pace, hoping to avoid IEDs or Maoist ambushes. The Maoists may be barefoot, but they are mobile and hidden and they know the terrain in-and-out. They always have the first shot, hidden deep within the jungle. The security personnel on combing operations can only return fire, or counter-attack, but by the time they’re aware of what’s happening, the PLGA disappears.

How are they going to militarily deal with the Maoists is beyond one’s imagination.

Of course, no one would want to admit that the adivasis gain absolutely nothing from Maoist attacks on police personnel as well. The Maoists would probably refer to the killing of 73 CRPF personnel as a major victory, but would the adivasi care? Does the killing of police personnel stop displacement? Does it protect his home and his village? Will the 700 villages that were burnt down or emptied by the Salwa Judum be rebuilt? Will it bring back the countless adivasis who were killed in fake encounters? No. Every attack that takes place, in whatever part of Dantewada or Bijapur district has only one direct consequence – the counter-terror unleashed onto the local populace. And the Maoists are fools if they believe that they are not responsible for the terror that would be unleashed onto the local population by the state.

I can imagine the numbers 73-74-75-76 repeating themselves, over and over again in the minds of the CRPF soldier manning a machine gun nest, or interrogating Muria men during combing operations. Fear breeds violence. Blood follows blood. Terror and counter-terror.



  1. The Maoists know all too well that they are 100% responsible for law enforcement’s brutality against the villagers. They welcome it. It’s a recruitment strategy.

  2. […] from one of India’s premier economic daily’s. I would also invite readers to read Javed Iqbal’s article on the recent killings by the Maoists. […]

  3. So true……….when are the adivasi voices ever ging to be heard? Will they have to bear the brunt over and ver and over again………

  4. Javed: The responses by PUDR and Sumanta Banerjee seem more apt.

  5. Why you did not wrote what ever did by police and army. How thy killed Adiwasis (Tribs) with their bullet. And these tribs not getting justice.

    • read the rest of the blog please.

  6. Quote
    I can imagine the numbers 73-74-75-76 repeating themselves, over and over again in the minds of the CRPF soldier manning a machine gun nest, or interrogating Muria men during combing operations. Fear breeds violence. Blood follows blood. Terror and counter-terror.

    Blood flows blood!

    Are we all just helpless stilled spectators to an unfolding gory and yet gripping drama?

  7. Maoists may consider the latest butchering of 75 policemen as a victory in their class war. These policemen were not from affluent sections to be considered as class enemies. They too have families. This will only encourage the security forces to be more ruthless against Maoists and the local people. Ultimately the poor people in general and the poorest locals in particular will pay a heavy price for the benefit of mining corporates and their well wishers in the HQs/capitals of the mineral rich districts, states and the nation.

  8. its anarchy all around…wen will it end???

  9. Who should make the start … 10 to 15 corporates that have fuelled the war are never going to say .. hey men look i have earned enough to last me generations .. so i would forgo my greed for more & a few ranks down in the fortune top 100 list is not going to make any difference…Agarwal was heard saying – chidu call off your men with guns & penis’s & let justice be given to the oldest inhabitants of the land.

    Reality check-

    Rape & kill while chidu roars we will finish them all .. boss do not worry just give me 90 more days .. &

    Maoists were expected to open their hearts & welcome the forces to wipe them out too as they had wiped off 644 villages… The Indian State profits from losses of lives, reaps from war .. so why should it stop

    The Ball is in whose courts….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: